Stringly Typed Booleans

Posted on by

I’m getting rather hacked off seeing boolean properties typed as strings. Stringly typed is a phrase I learnt off a post from the excellent Coding Horror blog and it describes a phenomena whereby properties that are of a specific type, e.g. Boolean, Date, int, are stored needlessly as strings.

I’m working on a website that communicates with a money laundering service to check whether an individual is “bad” or not. Individuals can pass the test, but importantly it is possible to pass the test with some warning flags raised. If any of the warning flags are raised then an email should be sent off to compliance for them to do…whatever it is they do. Fair enough right?

The warning flags are obviously booleans. There was either a warning raised or there wasn’t – there are no two ways about it (no pun intended). In the serialized response, the warning flags are encoded as “Yes” or “No”…which is understandable. Now, upon receiving the response, it is parsed and turned into an internal representation. This is where things get really weird. The programmer that coded the object that stores the response from the service has decided to encode the warnings as strings, initialised to “”. Which is totally fucking bonkers.

Why?

Well, now our boolean warnings aren’t really booleans – they have WAY more than two possible values and the meaning of these values is subjective. One may consider “”, null, “No” as false, but could conceivably also consider “false” or “0″. We get the same sort of problem with true – “Yes”, “1″, “true” and then we get a whole load of unknown values which is every other possible string in the world. Which might be considered to be true.

So how the hell can any number of programmers work on this piece of code without introducing errors because of differing definitions of truthy and falsey values? Well, they can’t. To illustrate the problem further, even loosely typed languages differ in their boolean coercion, for example JavaScript and PHP:

<script>
if("0") alert('Opposite day!');
</script>

<?php
if("0") echo 'Opposite day!';
?>

JavaScript considers “0″ true but PHP considers it false. Personally I think JavaScript is “right” here, but as I said before, it is totally subjective.

The icing on the cake is of course the extra code you have to write to check the truthy or falsey string values. Something along the lines of “if x is not null and not empty and not the word No then it is probably true…probably”, which would otherwise have been coded as “if x then true” if x was a boolean – which is orders of magnitude shorter.

Of course, there are some bat shit crazy strongly typed languages that allow you to assign null to a Boolean, but that is a different story altogether.

23,143 thoughts on “Stringly Typed Booleans”

  1. Do you mind if I quote a couple of your articles as long as I provide
    credit and sources back to your blog? My website is in the
    very same area of interest as yours and my users would
    really benefit from some of the information you present here.
    Please let me know if this alright with you. Regards!

  3. Частная наркологическая клиника организует лечение запоя на дому амбулаторное сопровождение медикаментозное снятие похмельного синдрома и лечение в стационаре. Нарколог выезжает круглосуточно оценивает физическое и психическое самочувствие пациента проверяет пульс и артериальное давление а затем определяет подходящий вариант лечения. Все услуги оказываются анонимно без передачи сведений по месту работы и без постановки на государственный учет. Подробнее – вывод из запоя круглосуточно

  7. Hello! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group?
    There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content.
    Please let me know. Thank you

  8. Помощь оказывают врачи с практикой в наркологии психиатрии и восстановительной терапии. Детальнее – vyvod iz zapoya klinika

  12. Принимаем заявки круглосуточно уточняем состояние и подбираем безопасный формат помощи. Получить дополнительные сведения – вызов нарколога на дом московская московская область

  14. new online usa casino, best poker online new zealand and casinos what game
    was played in casino royale (Lukas) saskatchewan united states, or is top online pokies and casinos united states pokies

  15. I absolutely love your blog.. Pleasant colors & theme. Did you make this site
    yourself? Please reply back as I’m attempting to create my own website and would love to learn where you
    got this from or just what the theme is named.
    Thank you!

  17. Москва всем привет Отец не выходит из штопора Дети напуганы Нужна срочная помощь на дому Короче единственное что вытащило из запоя — вывод из запоя в Москве круглосуточно Сняли ломку и стабилизировали состояние В общем телефон и цены тут — цены на вывод из запоя на дому в москве https://czena.vyvod-iz-zapoya-na-domu-moskva.ru Вывод из запоя на дому — это реальный выход Перешлите тем кто в такой же ситуации