Java interface and implementation naming (or “I” or “Impl”)

Posted on by

How do I name my interfaces and the classes that implement my interfaces? Through much research on the internet and my own gut feelings, this is what I reckon:

I never prefix my interfaces with “I”. The value of coding to interfaces is that you can swap out the implementation with minimal hassle. It means that instead of using implementation specific class names in your code, you use interface names instead – right? So, if I’m going to be using interface names everywhere, I don’t want to have to prefix everything with “I”. Coding to interfaces is a best practice, so I don’t need to explicitly state that I am doing it…It should just happen – which makes the “I” prefix redundant.

Furthermore, the “Impl” suffix is also redundant. Yes, indeed, your dilemma isn’t as simple as picking between the two. Firstly, “Impl” doesn’t translate. “Impl” in other languages has no meaning, and yes I’m talking about Polish and Scala. In Polish (according to Google translate), “implementation” is “realizacja” and in Scala, there are no interfaces. The closest thing Scala has to interfaces is traits, which can contain implementation specific code. So really, everything is Scala is an implementation, so why you use “Impl” suffix?

Secondly “Impl” is restrictive. What happens when you want to add another implementation of Foo? You gonna call it “FooImplImpl”? “AnotherFooImpl”? “FooImpl2″? I didn’t think so. Perhaps you were going to just call it “FooImpl” and put it in a different package…

Thirdly “Impl” doesn’t convey any meaning about what the implementation is. You wouldn’t create an “AnimalImpl” would you? You’d create a “Lion” or an “Elephant”. There is almost always something that distinguishes your implementation that you can use in the class name. Even if it is a long name, it doesn’t matter – you’re coding to interfaces (remember?), so you’re rarely going to see that class name.

Lastly, and probably most importantly – you still can’t think of a name? You don’t need an interface. If you really can’t think of a name, your class must be generic enough to not need an interface and you’re probably not going to have any other implementations. Your class methods become the interface contract, and that is that.

1,908 thoughts on “Java interface and implementation naming (or “I” or “Impl”)”

  16. Официальное получение водительского удостоверения в России Купить права в России — важный этап для каждого водителя который хочет уверенно и законно управлять транспортным средством. Мы предлагаем информационную поддержку по всем этапам оформления: выбор автошколы подготовка к теоретическому экзамену практические занятия сбор необходимых документов и подача заявления в ГИБДД. Получение водительского удостоверения категории B официально и без лишних сложностей. Поможем пройти все этапы законно: подготовка к теории обучение практическому вождению запись на экзамены консультации по документам и сопровождение до получения прав. Услуга подойдет тем кто хочет сэкономить время избежать ошибок при оформлении и уверенно пройти процедуру получения прав. Поддержка на каждом этапе понятные инструкции и помощь в подготовке к сдаче экзамена в ГИБДД. Категория B позволяет управлять легковыми автомобилями и является наиболее востребованной для личного и семейного использования.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>